It's good to see they're still making newspaper movies
ShareThisThe release of State of Play, a new Hollywood film starring Russell Crowe as a newspaper journalist, has prompted comparison between newsrooms portrayed on film and the troubled newsrooms in Canada today.
Jay Stone of Canwest News Service writes:
"In State of Play, Russell Crowe plays a hard-hitting journalist who sets out with his partner, Rachel McAdams, to solve a murder under the direction of ruthless editor Helen Mirren. This is quite a cast and quite an assignment. In today's real newsrooms, the ruthless editor would be trying to figure out how she's going to cover four city meetings with one reporter and a freelancer, and the murder investigation would be assigned to a summer intern who would have to fit it in around the annual strawberry picking feature...
Some day they'll be making movies about hard-hitting bloggers who set out to solve the case of how the Hollywood star got drunk and said something stupid: anything as complex and time-consuming as the Watergate investigation would have to be left to real investigative reporters, like Jon Stewart."
The New York Times' reviewer wonders if the images of a news story making its way from a computer screen to newsprint (complete with plates set and presses "whirring") "may look as quaint as engravings of stagecoaches and steam engines" in a few years time.
But as Stone says, "It's good to see they're still making newspaper movies."
Times reviewer A.O. Scott writes:
"Those of us who work in the newspaper business are highly susceptible to the kind of sentimental view of our trade this movie offers, especially when the sentiment masquerades as tough-minded cynicism, which makes us go all dewy and reach for the bottle of rye we keep stashed in the bottom drawer of our battered metal desk. And anyone, in whatever field, who cherishes memories of “All the President’s Men” or “His Girl Friday” will smile when “State of Play,” directed by Kevin Macdonald (“The Last King of Scotland”), now and again hits the sweet spot of the genre."
Jay Stone of Canwest News Service writes:
"In State of Play, Russell Crowe plays a hard-hitting journalist who sets out with his partner, Rachel McAdams, to solve a murder under the direction of ruthless editor Helen Mirren. This is quite a cast and quite an assignment. In today's real newsrooms, the ruthless editor would be trying to figure out how she's going to cover four city meetings with one reporter and a freelancer, and the murder investigation would be assigned to a summer intern who would have to fit it in around the annual strawberry picking feature...
Some day they'll be making movies about hard-hitting bloggers who set out to solve the case of how the Hollywood star got drunk and said something stupid: anything as complex and time-consuming as the Watergate investigation would have to be left to real investigative reporters, like Jon Stewart."
The New York Times' reviewer wonders if the images of a news story making its way from a computer screen to newsprint (complete with plates set and presses "whirring") "may look as quaint as engravings of stagecoaches and steam engines" in a few years time.
But as Stone says, "It's good to see they're still making newspaper movies."
Times reviewer A.O. Scott writes:
"Those of us who work in the newspaper business are highly susceptible to the kind of sentimental view of our trade this movie offers, especially when the sentiment masquerades as tough-minded cynicism, which makes us go all dewy and reach for the bottle of rye we keep stashed in the bottom drawer of our battered metal desk. And anyone, in whatever field, who cherishes memories of “All the President’s Men” or “His Girl Friday” will smile when “State of Play,” directed by Kevin Macdonald (“The Last King of Scotland”), now and again hits the sweet spot of the genre."
Comment Policy
J-Source invites comments on any content items or on any other topics relevant to journalism. Those posting comments are expected to adhere to standards of accuracy and fairness that would be recognized by those who practise, teach or study journalism.
- Comments are restricted to registered users. You must register with your full first and last name in order to be eligible to comment.
- Please communicate as effectively and intelligently as you would in a professional or academic forum, focusing on the issues at hand rather than the characters or characteristics of those involved.
- This forum is intended for discussion of the craft of journalism, not of the issues of the day that journalists cover; please do not post story tips or press releases.
- We moderate the forum for adherence to these standards of discourse, and reserve the right to decline any comment or restrict any user from commenting without giving reasons. Every effort is made to approve valid comments within 24 hours of submission.
J-Source and ProjetJ are projects of The Canadian Journalism Foundation in collaboration with leading schools and organizations across Canada. Editor-in-chief, J-Source: | |||
Recent Posts
2012-05-16 12:30
2012-05-16 10:53
On Rob Ford, Daniel Dale and Fencegate: Journalists, stand together for access to information
"At present, the target is Daniel Dale—against a colourful backdrop of vitriol from...
Deux nouveaux médias québécois: Les News et Le République
Je suis surpris que M. Lajoie a pris le nom anglophone LesNews pour son site. Il existe déjà sur...
Call for submissions for the 2012 Dave Greber Freelance Writers Awards
The 2012 Dave Greber Freelance Writers Awards is obviously a nice opportunity for everyone!...