Jury uses new defence, dismisses libel suit against news site, police
ShareThisIn one of the first uses of a new journalistic defence, the Ontario Superior Court of Justice has dismissed a
multimillion-dollar libel suit brought forward by a former accountant
against news site SooToday.com and the Sault Ste. Marie Police Service.
Kofi Hadjor, a former Toronto chartered accountant, alleged that a fraud alert issued by Police and posted on SooToday.com contained defamatory errors. Hadjor was convicted ten years ago of defrauding clients in the film and entertainment industry.
The jury ruled that that alert was true and the "errors not significant enough to materially injure Hadjor's reputation", SooToday.com reports.
The judge, Super Court Justice Edward Koko, noted that the case is one of the first jury cases to use the new journalistic defence of responsible communication, which was established last December by the Supreme Court of Canada. The defence is available to journalists that can prove they have used due diligence to verify information that serves the public interest. SooToday.com provided evidence that between 20 and 30 sources were consulted for their report.
SooToday.com reports:
"Publication of the alert by Rollin and City Police was protected by the defence of qualified privilege because police had a duty to issue the alert and the business community had a corresponding interest in receiving it, Sault lawyer John Walker successfully argued.
"Testimony during the two-week trial at the Sault Ste. Marie Court House indicated that Hadjor was interested in buying and renovating Salzburger Hof Resort at Batchawana Bay and the Buckeye resort.
"He hoped to persuade charities serving the Canadian poor to send 1,000 staffers to Batchawana at a cost of at least $3,700 each, to listen to presentations by Hadjor, learn how to access government funding and participate in local eco-tourism activities including the Agawa Canyon Tour Train.
"An independent analysis of the plan, commissioned by SooToday.com from BDO Dunwoody, cast doubt on its viability."
Kofi Hadjor, a former Toronto chartered accountant, alleged that a fraud alert issued by Police and posted on SooToday.com contained defamatory errors. Hadjor was convicted ten years ago of defrauding clients in the film and entertainment industry.
The jury ruled that that alert was true and the "errors not significant enough to materially injure Hadjor's reputation", SooToday.com reports.
The judge, Super Court Justice Edward Koko, noted that the case is one of the first jury cases to use the new journalistic defence of responsible communication, which was established last December by the Supreme Court of Canada. The defence is available to journalists that can prove they have used due diligence to verify information that serves the public interest. SooToday.com provided evidence that between 20 and 30 sources were consulted for their report.
SooToday.com reports:
"Publication of the alert by Rollin and City Police was protected by the defence of qualified privilege because police had a duty to issue the alert and the business community had a corresponding interest in receiving it, Sault lawyer John Walker successfully argued.
"Testimony during the two-week trial at the Sault Ste. Marie Court House indicated that Hadjor was interested in buying and renovating Salzburger Hof Resort at Batchawana Bay and the Buckeye resort.
"He hoped to persuade charities serving the Canadian poor to send 1,000 staffers to Batchawana at a cost of at least $3,700 each, to listen to presentations by Hadjor, learn how to access government funding and participate in local eco-tourism activities including the Agawa Canyon Tour Train.
"An independent analysis of the plan, commissioned by SooToday.com from BDO Dunwoody, cast doubt on its viability."
Comment Policy
J-Source invites comments on any content items or on any other topics relevant to journalism. Those posting comments are expected to adhere to standards of accuracy and fairness that would be recognized by those who practise, teach or study journalism.
- Comments are restricted to registered users. You must register with your full first and last name in order to be eligible to comment.
- Please communicate as effectively and intelligently as you would in a professional or academic forum, focusing on the issues at hand rather than the characters or characteristics of those involved.
- This forum is intended for discussion of the craft of journalism, not of the issues of the day that journalists cover; please do not post story tips or press releases.
- We moderate the forum for adherence to these standards of discourse, and reserve the right to decline any comment or restrict any user from commenting without giving reasons. Every effort is made to approve valid comments within 24 hours of submission.
 | Support J-Source | ||
 | Best online-only article or series | ||
J-Source and ProjetJ are projects of The Canadian Journalism Foundation in collaboration with leading schools and organizations Editor-in-chief, J-Source: | |||
Postmedia and Ottawa Citizen stories on "Robocalls" win Michener Award
I'm glad that Maher and McGregor and the Ottawa Citizen were recognized for the work they...
Attention journalists: Federal government makes data site more searchable
As always, the most comprehensive and up-to-date listing of Canadian open data sites can be...
Official list of Globe and Mail staff who took the buyouts
Why is this nice easy list of names with subheds not published as plain HTML (H2, OL, LI) with...