Media coverage and the right to a fair trial
[node:ad]
The Eaton Centre shooting and the Luka Magnotta case have received a lot of media attention — but will this coverage have an effect on the accused’s right to a fair trial? Luka Magnotta’s case caught the media’s attention quickly when two body parts were mailed to two Canadian political parties. He is also alleged to have posted the video of the murder and acts cannibalism online. Because new events continue to unfold, the case is still prominent in the media. Some experts say it may have an effect on Magnotta’s trial because it is difficult for the public to be objective after everything it has heard. The same may be true for Christopher Husbands, who allegedly killed one man and injured several others in last weekend’s Eaton Centre shooting. The story spread quickly via social media (a professional athlete actually broke the story) and affects a large number of people and their perceived sense of safety and outlook on Toronto. After almost every major Toronto media outlet had identified the victims of the shooting, a publication ban was placed on their names. That said, these are not the first Canadian incidents where the right to a fair trial may be compromised by media coverage.
Angelina King is a freelance journalist who works as a reporter for CTV News Channel in Toronto. She previously reported for CTV in her hometown of Saskatoon and is a graduate of Ryerson University's journalism program. Angelina has a special interest in court and justice reporting, but is always grateful to share a human interest story. You can reach her at: @angelinakCTV.
June 6, 2012
Suppose you got shot and
Suppose you got shot and the media was banned from reporting it? A rule which was created for specific reasons being applied in a blanket fashion. Another reason why JPs should be lawyers not former high school principles and spouses of powerfully connected politicians.
Ironically, the 13-year-old's name would have been banned from publication if the shooter was under 18 because of a twist the law covering young offenders.
And the accused's right to a fair trial? Police kept Husband's name off the record until he was charged. How does that risk his right to a fair trial? He's on video camera and he's been identified by the surviving victim?
And Magnotta? He gave up his right to any protections when he posted himself in a video in the act.
Duh.